TFL Vsebine / Revija Pravnik

7

Ekipa Pravne fakultete Univerze v Ljubljani se je letos udeležila mednarodnega tekmovanja Sports Law Arbitration Moot, na katerem se je uvrstila med štiri najboljše ekipe. Tekmovalci so se na tekmovanju soočili z dvema fiktivnima primeroma s področja športnega prava. Prvi primer je obravnaval problematiko dopinga v nogometu, kjer sta bili ključni vprašanji, kdaj je dosežen dokazni standard balance ob probabilites in ali je športniku uspelo svojo zgodbo predstaviti dovolj prepričljivo, da se je ta panelu CAS zdela bolj verjetna kot ne. Drugi fiktivni primer se je osredotočal na disciplinske postopke v konjeništvu. Odprl je številne pravne probleme, med drugim tudi vprašanje (pre) velike abstraktnosti norm mednarodnih športnih zvez in njihove posledice. Odprlo se je tudi vprašanje presoje sorazmernosti sankcije in kako to presojati, če ni primerljivih preteklih primerov. Poleg tega pa se je primer dotaknil tudi morebitne kršitve 6. člena Evropske konvencije o človekovih pravicah.

This year, the team from the Faculty of Law at the University of Ljubljana participated in the international Sports Law Arbitration Moot competition, where they ranked among the top four teams. The competitors faced two hypothetical cases in the field of sports law. The first case centred on doping in football, focusing primarily on the evidential standard of balance of probabilities. The hey question was whether the athlete in the case could convince the CAS panel that his scenario was more likely than not. The second hypothetical case pertained to disciplinary procedures in equestrian sport. It raised several legal issues, including the high level of abstraction in the norms of international sports federations and their consequences. The case also explored the challenge of assessing the proportionality of a sanction in the absence of comparable precedents. Additionally, the case touched upon a potential violation of Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Open Issues of Disciplinary Procedures in Sports